CAN WE STILL TALK? Finding Common Ground In A Divided America

Hot Topic Bold Talk | Freedom And Security

 

Two Americans, Different Political Perspectives, and One Essential Commitment: We Can Still Talk!

How much freedom are Americans willing to surrender in the name of security? Who gets to make that decision? And what happens when the people entrusted with protecting our freedoms appear to operate under different rules from those governing ordinary citizens?

These are some of the challenging questions explored in Podcast 202 of Hot Topic Bold Talk by Dr. Jackalyn, featuring Nigel M. Lakey and Dr. Jackalyn Rainosek in their continuing series, CAN WE STILL TALK? Finding Common Ground in a Divided America.

Nigel, a Reagan-Thatcher conservative, engineer, entrepreneur, and naturalized American citizen, brings his commitment to individual liberty, constitutional principles, and limited government to this discussion. Jackalyn, a liberal Democrat, mental health professional, and organizational development consultant, brings her commitment to civil rights, constitutional protections, ethical leadership, and the importance of understanding human behavior.

Their political perspectives are different. Their commitment to meaningful conversation is shared.

Freedom, Security, and the Responsibilities of Government

Nigel begins with a powerful principle: “We cannot allow security to outweigh freedom.”

This statement opens a conversation about the delicate balance between protecting American citizens and preserving the constitutional freedoms that define our democracy.

The discussion explores government surveillance, expanding technologies, national security, and the increasing ability of governments and corporations to collect information about ordinary citizens.

When does protection become intrusion? How do we determine when security measures go too far? And who protects citizens when the institutions responsible for their security become threats to their individual freedoms?

Nigel provides examples of situations in which security measures and government actions have limited individual liberty, raising important questions about the consequences for American citizens.

When Those in Power Appear to Live by Different Rules

Jackalyn and Nigel also examine the issue of insider trading and the troubling perception that ordinary Americans are held accountable for conduct that powerful individuals may escape consequences for.

Without naming specific individuals, they explore what happens to public trust when citizens believe that government officials and influential people have opportunities or protections unavailable to everyone else.

Can Americans maintain confidence in their government when accountability appears to depend on who holds power?

Their conversation raises fundamental questions about fairness, ethical leadership, equal treatment under the law, and the responsibilities that accompany positions of public trust.

The Arms Race: Have Our Leaders Failed to Protect Our Future?

Another important area of discussion concerns the continuing arms race and the failure of successive presidential administrations to adequately address its growing dangers.

Jackalyn and Nigel share their concerns that the last five administrations have not sufficiently confronted this problem and that the risks have continued to increase.

Their conversation examines the relationship between national security, military power, international responsibility, and the long-term consequences of allowing an increasingly dangerous arms race to continue.

Are we creating greater security through expanding military capabilities, or are we increasing the dangers future generations will inherit?

When Partisanship Becomes More Important Than People

Jackalyn brings another dimension to the discussion: the powerful influence of human behavior, attitudes, and extreme partisan positions on the decisions people make.

She shares two contrasting examples.

In one situation, individuals were able to move beyond their initial reactions, listen to different perspectives, and work through a difficult incident to reach a better decision.

In another, a one-sided partisan discussion contributed to a harmful decision with serious consequences for an individual and the citizens of a county.

These examples demonstrate that the way people communicate can be just as important as the issues they are attempting to resolve.

When people become committed to defending a political position rather than understanding a situation, they may stop listening to information that could lead to better decisions.

The consequences can be deeply personal, affecting not only the individuals involved, but entire communities.

Criticism Divides Us. Listening Creates Possibilities.

One of the most meaningful parts of this podcast is Jackalyn’s discussion of the difference between destructive criticism and communication that helps people grow.

Criticism, negative labeling, and personal attacks frequently produce defensiveness, anger, and conflict. Once people feel attacked, meaningful conversation becomes increasingly difficult.

Jackalyn introduces her approach to feed-forward, a constructive alternative that allows individuals to receive observations about their behavior, understand how their actions affect others, and consider changes that can improve relationships and future outcomes.

Equally important is creating opportunities for people to express their thoughts, feelings, and experiences while knowing they are genuinely being heard.

These communication skills are essential not only in political conversations, but also in families, organizations, workplaces, and communities.

We cannot find solutions when we are unwilling to hear one another.

Two Different Perspectives. One Powerful Demonstration.

Throughout this podcast, Jackalyn and Nigel demonstrate something increasingly uncommon in American political conversations.

There are moments when one does not fully support what the other is saying.

They acknowledge their differences.

They question ideas.

They express their own perspectives.

And they continue talking.

Neither person needs to surrender personal convictions to maintain respect for the other.

Neither needs to win an argument.

Their purpose is to understand, explore important issues, and discover where common ground may exist.

This is the central message of their continuing series.

Finding common ground does not require us to think alike. It requires us to recognize that another person’s perspective deserves to be heard.

An Invitation to Our Listeners

Podcast 202 invites listeners to consider two essential questions:

How do we protect our national security without sacrificing the freedoms that make America worth protecting?

And how can we make better decisions for our country when we have lost the ability to talk respectfully with people who see the world differently?

Freedom and security are not simply political issues. They affect our daily lives, our constitutional rights, our relationships, and the future we are creating for the next generation.

Jackalyn and Nigel remind us that thoughtful conversations between people with different political beliefs are not only possible; they are necessary.

We can challenge ideas without attacking people.

We can express deeply held convictions while remaining open to learning.

We can acknowledge differences without allowing those differences to destroy relationships.

And perhaps most importantly, we can discover that the willingness to listen may open doors to solutions we could never find alone.

Join Dr. Jackalyn Rainosek and Nigel M. Lakey for Podcast 202, an engaging and thought-provoking conversation about freedom, security, ethical leadership, partisan behavior, and the communication skills that can help Americans find a better way forward.

CAN WE STILL TALK? Yes, we can. And Jackalyn and Nigel are showing us how.

Episode Summary Points

  • Explored the delicate balance between personal freedom and state security, emphasizing that neither should completely override the other.
  • Examined the concept of “technopoly” and the growing concerns surrounding corporate data harvesting, algorithms, and the modern surveillance state.
  • Discussed the challenges of government overreach, immigration policy enforcement, and the importance of upholding the rule of law.
  • Highlighted the critical need for political term limits and leveling the playing field to reduce corruption and ensure accountability among elected officials.
  • Addressed the dangers of political polarization, emotional voting, and the importance of moving past headline rhetoric to engage in reasoned civic discourse.
  • Emphasized the vital role of civic education and historical awareness in preserving the foundational principles of a constitutional republic.
  • Evaluated geopolitical realities and the strategic importance of international alliances in a changing global landscape.

—

Watch the episode here

 

Listen to the podcast here

 

Can We Still Talk? Finding Common Ground In A Divided America

I am delighted that Nigel and I are going to have a wonderful conversation. We both have concepts of freedom, and we both have concepts around security. I would really like Nigel to begin because you made a comment in some of the notes that we took in exchange with each other. We cannot allow security to outweigh freedom. I would really like to understand what you’re talking about. I want to repeat it again so the audience can hear it. We cannot allow security to outweigh freedom. You and I both have a lot of ideas about this. I’m going to start with you first, please.

The Core Tension Between Freedom And Government Overreach

Welcome, everybody. Winter in South Texas, getting over a few days of rain. Let me frame up that comment, if you will, and probably more about anything defining both of those terms. Freedom is, I’m not saying it’s anarchy, and that’s important. That’s an extreme. We do have rules. We do have moral guidelines. We’ve got ethical guidelines. We’ve got a lot of things that aren’t so much part of the Constitution, but they’re part of the cultural fabric of where this came from. That’s brought in by immigrants, etc.

The security part of it, the extreme of that, and it may not be a great example, but think about North Korea or think about any highly regulated country. You say you do not have an open internet. You’ve got a closed banking system. People cannot get in, cannot get out. Are they secure? Their leadership wants the populace to believe that they’re secure. If you think about those two extremes, one where there’s anarchy, where you have no rules. That’s freedom. There really isn’t. That imposes on everybody else a risk.

The ultra-secure side similarly imposes on the population a pile of burdens that they cannot do anything. They cannot go anywhere. Those things that we’ve accepted as freedoms and liberties, they’re denied. You can either say freedom counts outweigh liberty or security, or security counts outweigh freedom. It’s more about we cannot allow ourselves to be so secure and under so much control, so much regulation, if you will, that our ability to do things. I’m going to get back to some of our original comments, which is the Constitution, the first articles of it, that’s the Bill of Rights. We’re all created equal.

Now, I know we’ve had conversations about what equal is equal. Not getting into those nuances, we cannot be so secure that we’re denied the freedoms that the Constitution provides us. I’ll turn it over to you here, but I’ll close my train of thought there. The risk is that government oversight, the surety of outcomes, and that sort of thing, government overreach more often puts our freedoms and our liberties at risk. We’ve got other conversations you can have on more detail there, but just to try and address your initial question, that’s where I was coming from.

 

Hot Topic Bold Talk | Freedom And Security

 

When I look at it, my freedoms are very important to me. I want to be, you mentioned North Korea, I want to be able to travel. I want to be able to have the right to speak out. I want to be able to have the right to vote and know that we have the freedom to make changes. We’ve seen some recently, I think, with the election, some changes from the voters and their statements to all of us.

One thing I do know is, there are certain things, though, that I think we need to have ways to have the government deal with overreach and to have some structure that helps us prevent ourselves from being in a situation where corruption occurs or where people make a decision that they’re going to take stands or do things that are detrimental to other human beings that are citizens of the United States. It’s a hard balance to know what it is. When you eliminate all overreach, or a majority of the overreach, then you do not have the protection for some of the things we do have when people that are in government make decisions to set guidelines.

I do not call them rules. They’re guidelines, because we have laws that are like rules. I have to abide by the law. They’re rules. The guidelines they set are the concepts and the principles in our Constitution. If we could sit here and talk about the problems that are existing where we see overreach in our freedoms or where we see a lack of security and have reasonable conversations, we might find some solutions to how these two words can be better handled. I’ll stop there and give you a chance to speak.

I appreciate that perspective. I’ll draw a distinction here. That’s a distinction with a difference that when I look at this from a constitutional perspective, the Constitution, it exists so that the people can give certain powers to the government. It’s not the other way. It was never intended that the government gives people certain rights. There are a lot of things in the Second Amendment debate. It really revolves around that. This notion of overreach, I think there’s overreach that begins to really infringe upon constitutional freedoms.

 

We cannot allow ourselves to be so controlled and regulated that our ability to act puts our fundamental freedoms and liberties at risk.

 

Now, there’s another issue under there, which is the rule of law, and I’m not a person who’s happy to stomach corruption or overreach, conversely. Maybe from conversations, from discussions, people can understand what these conditions and what these scenarios may be, but I think, getting back to liberty and freedom, if you will, those are the constitutional elements. I would say security. We have to be careful when we use the term. What does it mean? I said at the outset, can we work to define those things?

If the government wants to make us so secure that we cannot do anything, then we’re deep into another political structure. You can say fascism, etc., but we do not want to go there. Nor do we want the point where everybody can just do whatever the hell they want. That again puts everybody else at risk. It is this balance, but we cannot have so much security or so much freedom that we do not have either. I do not really know how to get there. There’s a track record of whoever is in power, and again we’re not pointing fingers at anybody, but of overreach and overextension, and you know where we’re seeing our freedoms infringed upon, if not outright crushed.

Political Polarization And Voting On Emotion

It appears that as a population we’ve begun to accept some of that. I would put my hand up, and it’s a bit of a warning, which is to say, let’s understand how much security we really want and need. I’m going to say, in a lot of the other conversations we’ve had, that if individuals are better educated and individuals have more civic and social responsibility, then maybe some of these things become less of an issue. I’m worried that we vote on our emotions. We do not vote on the real issues. We do not like this. That’s how we cast our vote.

Both of us see people at the extremes, and that’s not healthy for us. Your point was, can we have a conversation? Can you have some dialogue on this and begin to understand? If we just drop into the rhetoric, we’re not going to get anywhere. We’ve said many times this is a generational issue. This is not one electoral cycle. Somewhere, our descendants, literally, metaphorically, whatever, maybe we’ll come to better terms and better grips with this. It sure feels like we’re a long way off.

We are, and I think you and I both know that. I always think it’s interesting, though. The public does finally decide how extreme something is, to the point that they get out and vote. I know in Harris County alone, they broke records every day. I’m glad to see that when people get concerned enough, they’re going to do something about at least voting and expressing their opinion. Now, I do not know about you. I read lots about every person I vote for. I spend a tremendous amount of time on it.

Technopoly, Surveillance, And Data Privacy Risks

One of the things that I’ve been thinking about is that you used a term in one of our papers, and I’d like to go there, and then I’d like to go and ask some questions that you and I have both seen, to see if we can really go more in-depth in what we’re talking about. I do not know what this is, and you mentioned the word technopoly. I want to know what that is, because I think it’s a word that may give us a chance to talk about where we sit in the middle to have a discussion about freedom and security so that we can have a discussion and then recommend or make some decisions to talk to other people and so forth. Start there for me, because I have no idea what the term means.

It’s invented. We can say it’s a combination of technology and monopoly. Do we want to be in this world where we’re governed by technology and technology has a monopoly? Think about our surveillance state. At one level, that’s controlled by a couple of these Magnificent Seven that are on the exchange. They have so much data on everything that we do. I’ve said that we’re maybe the most highly surveilled state on the face of the earth. That’s not government surveillance. Put Flock cameras aside. We’ve got laws that allow that data to be harvested.

 

Do we want to be in this world where we’re governed by technology and technology having a monopoly?

 

Some algorithms are created by that data. I do not know what your newsfeed is like, but I tell you, mine is full of so much crap that is of no value to me, but somebody thinks that I need to be influenced. The technology, to me, may not be there yet, but it’s on the horizon. It’s that overwhelming surveillance state where everything that we do is governed by information, influenced by information that somebody else has, managed by an algorithm. To me, that’s a real danger.

Now, it’s as much a risk of indoctrination, if you will, because this becomes your central source of information. The human stops really looking for stuff, just gets fed it and consumes it because we do not know any better. That’s a genuine risk. We need to better define it. We need to better understand what the symptoms are, but I think it’s really this risk of the surveillance state. A small number of enterprises having all the information and effectively reaching for control. Now, that’s genuine overreach. Some states have a limit on the information.

California’s got a Do Not Sell My Information Act. Texas does not. A whole bunch of other states do not. Somewhat, as a rule, the US doesn’t. Other countries may have gone too far. This flow of data, this capture of personal information, that’s got to have some pretty strong regulations to it. That goes to another topic we’re going to have to get our heads around soon. This whole notion of AI.

We’ll get there. Let me make some comments about that. I’m just going to talk. I’m not talking about headlines. I’m talking about things I notice and things that I read about. I try to read conservative references, and I make an effort to read liberal ones. I try to combine those and do something with them. I’ve chosen specific things that I read on a daily basis. That’s probably twenty different resources. I’m not getting inundated by one specific position.

One of the things when you talk about tech and monopolies, and you said seven, but it concerns me that one individual can decide on what’s going to happen in a war based on what he has access to and the ability to do with what he’s developed. To me, that’s a monopoly. Another thing that I think really concerns me is that I do not think it’s reasonable for some of the things that we have about health care for human beings. We have HIPAA, but it seems to be ignored. There’s an effort to overreach and get those things so that they can do something with it with ICE.

I’m seeing things where I think they’re overreaching, and I’m sitting here, and I’m saying, when do we say to the representatives that we have in Congress or the judges we elect, “Here’s what we do not like about this overreach.” I personally do not think it’s right to give out information. I did not when it was happening. I do not think it’s right to give out tax information as a way to find out who is, because I know some immigrants pay taxes all the time. They want to be American citizens, and so they do the right thing.

We have some examples of the technology and the monopoly and how it’s happening. My question all the time is, where do we need government intervention because of what’s happening and how it’s impacting certain citizens? Where do we need to make a decision so that it’s not overreach, and it is needed to manage those people that seem to have a hard time that live in this country that want to dominate, want to monopolize their power, and do something that I think is destructive? I’ll stop there, and I’ll leave it to you for a moment, Nigel.

Immigration Policy, Rule Of Law, And Accountability

Let me throw this out. That’s everything that we’re trying to get our heads around here, whether it’s at the ballot or just in everyday life, is a consequence of some other decision that somebody else made. It’s not about going back and finding out who to blame, but we’re faced with, I think we’re faced with some unpleasant realities. As a consequence of overreach or ignorance or somebody just failing to realize that we do have a rule of law, some of this comes from the fact that policy, even inactive policy, informal policy, has flown in the face of law, of doctrine, of true passed acts.

We’ve got an issue with ICE because, frankly, we’ve had an administration that failed to enforce laws of the land on immigration. I’m not trying to say one’s right and one’s wrong. The conservative in me says there was a law that was just flagrantly abused for years. Now we’ve got a consequence of that abuse. The consequence is not very pleasant. Now, the reasonable conservative in me says that doesn’t mean that anybody’s got the right to abuse human beings.

We are faced with this situation where sooner or later, we have to decide that we’re going to uphold the law, take on a piece of security. That doesn’t really infringe on your and my freedoms, which, as I’ve said before, those rights and privileges, etc., that protection is guaranteed to citizens. The protections in the Constitution do not apply to non-citizens. Now, that may sound heartless, but I do believe we really have to make up our minds about what it is we’re going to do. I’m not sure that we’re there yet as a society, as a conservative.

Again, as a Reagan-Thatcher conservative, I would say conservatives haven’t really decided where they are, and I do not think that the liberals have decided where they are. Extremists on both sides may have a point. They may have a decision about where they are. Frankly, I do not think as a society, as a culture, we do. Again, we’ve got a problem because we’ve had years and years of problems where it’s just been kicked down the road. We’re no longer having reasonable discourse at the political level.

Our elected officials are doing nothing more than threatening to investigate their predecessors, and they’re not going to solve the problems that we voted on and on which they got elected. That’s my current fear. I’ve just seen this over the past years and years in this country and in many others. I do not know that we’re voting for the right people on either side of the spectrum. I will say the one thing that really stood out to me in this past election, and not to get into those headlines because I’m not there, but damn it, that just absolutely made me resolute on this thing of term limits.

Term Limits And Leveling The Political Playing Field

A bunch of people, they shouldn’t even have been running. I do not know how they got primaried to begin with, let alone got subsequently elected four times. That’s one thing. That would root out a whole lot of the corruption that both you and I are worried about. If people realize that if they got elected, they had a job to do for a set number of years instead of getting into a career. There’s a whole bunch of other things in there, too.

That’s, the elected Congress and Senate should be on the same health care plan that the rest of us have to deal with. Level the playing field, I think. If whosoever in power truly wants to do that thing, then that would serve you and I so well and make a huge difference in what we vote on next time. I do not know if they have the guts for it, but I hope they do because that would begin to unwind a lot of these other problems.

I just say this. See, I am comfortable with what happened in this election, and I am comfortable with the people that I voted for. I’ve had lots of conversations with the people I voted for. I voted for a Republican in Missouri County because I thought he was the more competent person, and I thought he had the history that needed to lead us in ways that we need, some changes in Brazoria County. I thought he was very valuable.

I spent an hour and a half with him, and I asked him a lot of questions and how he was going to support some people that I know are not being treated reasonably because it’s been dominated in Brazoria County that the Republican Party was able to dominate it for many years, and it’s not happening now. One of the things I think, Nigel, that I see, if we have two parties that function and talk about the issues and truly commit to working on those issues, and I think some people are committed to doing that.

Now, I think there’s going to be some fights about billionaire results and all kinds of things. I accept that those things are probably going to be investigated because most of the time a president of the United States does not leave office and is a billionaire. That’s not something that happens. Some things are going to happen. What I would like to say is you may be a conservative, and I’m a liberal, but the thing is, I have to keep asking myself, “What do people have the right to have as a liberty, and what do they need to surrender in order to have security?”

That’s one of the questions we have on our sheet. There are certain things by the rule of law that are, for me, the rule of law and the systematic use of the laws that we have in the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, and the amendments. We have the opportunity to say, “These are things that are not allowed.” That’s what the court does a lot of times. They say, “We’re not going to allow this to happen because it is more harmful to the larger group of citizens than it is to satisfy the desire of a smaller group of people.”

I’m not that far off from you. The biggest issue anybody has to ask is, “What are the liberties that we will allow? How do those liberties allow us to have security?” I’m going to put it out there. When a person does not abide by the law or does not agree with the Constitution, or does not like it, and continues to fight in court about all kinds of things. To me, when you keep getting decisions that are clear about what the law says, and you refuse to abide by that, or you push it farther, that person, I think, is taking liberties that are unacceptable. There comes a time when the security of our nation, when the rule of law is not the central focus of our citizens or the representatives we have in our government, I think it creates tremendous difficulty. I’ll stop for a moment.

I’m going to say that’s an issue of interpretation of statutes, language, etc., and there’s nothing new. I would say you can easily pull examples out of the air. Either of us could. That’s not what we’re trying to accomplish, though. Your original question is what freedoms or liberties do we want to sacrifice? I do not think we really have to sacrifice any. I will say there’s ample provision. Let’s think about fraud activity. Coercion, corruption. We have laws on the books that say you cannot do that.

Now, it falls to legislatures. It falls to the control processes we have in government and civics, etc., to enforce those laws. Now, everybody’s got the right to stand in front of a jury. If you’re a jury of your peers, you can elect to have a jury, bench, trial, whatever. You can talk about the mechanics there. At a basic level, it’s people’s beliefs, values, and morals as they stand there. They would look at the law. They would look at the intent of the individual. Not trying to get into details here, but I do not know that we have to give up a lot of freedom to get security.

We have the amendments of the Constitution that would guarantee us the right to life and liberty. Nobody can take our life or liberty away. There is a risk at the government level, at the administrative level, whatever, civic, on its way up of people being enriched and being persuaded to take certain opinions and take certain actions because it benefits them personally.

That justice exists at every level. Now, I’m going to get back just briefly to this concept of term limits and the ability for a population to recall the elected official. There’s a handful of things. That’s permitted. There’s nothing in the Constitution that says you can get elected over and over again that could easily be changed. People just have to want to do it to set the term limits.

I do not know that political will exists. The uniparty does not want to get voted out, does not want to hit the street. Here’s John Cornyn basically saying, “I need a job.” It’s good that he got primaried out. There’s a lot of other people who got primaried out because they’re not working for you or me or anybody any longer. It’s become a career. Let me get off my soapbox there.

Let me interrupt something and say, I love term limits ideas. I would like to see that for the courts, definitely. I’d like to see it for Congress, and I’d like to see it through the Senate. It needs to be in my county. There need to be limits on how long you can serve. There are limits for our mayor, but for a lot of the other positions, there are no limits. You can keep running and running until somebody beats you. They’re not representing because what happens is they are going to go talk to the people that have the money to help them get elected. They’re not paying any attention.

I’m reinforcing your ideas. They’re not paying any attention to what the citizens in my county or in any county really need. They tend to, if they have more power in one party than another party, if they last for many, many years, then they get even more isolated and do not even want to hear a citizen from one party because the other party is in control. That’s when I think we lose control. Our freedom. That’s when people get pissed off. That’s when people start criticizing everybody and labeling everybody and doing all those things. I’m not going to get into something I’m involved in right now to try to stop some of that.

I have written some papers and done some things to talk to some individuals and say, criticism and labeling do nothing except this person says it and the person on the opposite side says, “No, that’s not it. Let me tell you how shitty you are.” We have a fight. What is needed is an understanding that no matter if you have 30% of one party and 70% of another, that 30% still has the right to be heard. That’s what I think term limits would do, but I think it needs to be acknowledged that no matter what your percentage is of one party or another party, you listened to all the citizens that you were representing.

I agree with that. Interestingly, the structure of the Senate provides for that mechanism. The Electoral College and a handful of things that some people despise, but they ensure that Texas is not overwhelmed by the voices from California or New York. There’s an elegance in the Constitution. When I’m one of these people who say I’m an originalist, those things, we shouldn’t mess with them because it could easily backfire. You’re right on a handful of counts. Here’s another one of these points where, damn it. We can sit here and say, I cannot throw rocks at you.

Don’t we hate that. If we diffuse, if we get out of the headlines and start thinking about real issues, you’ve got a set of ideals. I’ve got a set of ideals. Whatever parties in power that I like aren’t serving you, and the converse is true at a basic level. We’re at this point. I do not know how we’ve become so fractured. Now, I’m not so naive as to think that we can just undo all of that. If we do not have the conversations and if the voters do not really think about the issues, there’s a whole bunch of other things we’ve talked about. We’ve got lawlessness at high levels in the government.

We’ve got lawlessness at low levels in the government. Our civic government. When you think about things like term limits and such, they would benefit us tremendously across the board. There’s the other issue here, which is, where are we going? Not just as a country, but as a bunch of people, populace, etc. That does get us back to the freedoms and the obligations, liberties, etc. Again, just to get to the question that you posed at the start, do we have to give up freedoms for security? I’m going to get back to how we define those things.

I want to be able to enjoy the rights that are given to me by the Constitution. We all want that. I want to be able to have my First Amendment rights to have a conversation with somebody, disagree with me, etc., and not be like Canada, for example, where if I were to post a meme that somebody doesn’t like, the UK, I’m at risk of spending time incarcerated. That is BS. That’s a freedom that’s evaporating. The interest, I do not know, of appeasing somebody that’s thinly veiled as security.

That doesn’t work. Do we have to give up security for freedom? No. We need to spend time trying to define what that is, and I agree with you on a handful of accounts. We cannot have people who are benefiting from the position of power unjustly. Look, if you’re a smart investor, if they went into office wealthy and they come out of office wealthy on balance, I do not know that is a bad thing. Nobody should go.

No, I support that. I understand.

When we see things like insider trading, that s***’s got to stop.

It’s got to.

That is people who are entitled and get liberties to do things the rest of us do not enjoy. Otherwise, we would be in jail. I do not know what I would get back to this whole thing about security versus freedom at the very high level. We’re at risk of overextending ourselves on either count and the other suffering. That is this really interesting balance that, as a country, I think that we enjoy that many others do not. We do have a good framework. I’m not sure that we’re interpreting all the time correctly. I also think that, again, we’ve got individuals who choose to take advantage of certain frailties or weaknesses, if you will, in that fabric.

By and large, I’m not sure that we should be asking ourselves, what are we willing to give up? That’s more like, how much will we tolerate? That’s not good to say, well, I’m willing to give up this. We’ve come to that point. Whoever we are, whatever party line we draw, we’re at that point where I think we’re trying to resolve how much we can tolerate. That’s not right. That’s not good for us.

That’s not healthy. We’re going to lose both freedoms. How do we get back to more reasoned conversations, and to dialogue? It’s not a screaming debate. Again, I think that what you and I are trying to do is not get into those debates, but think about these higher-level ideas. Hopefully people, when they walk away, go, “I’m going to have a conversation with somebody,” or “I’m going to spend some time trying to understand something more than I do at this point.”

One of the things I want to suggest that just came to me with the statements you made, Nigel, if we could have a conversation and have a dialogue about it. If we could say, “This incident occurred in our county,” or “This incident occurred in the state,” or “This incident occurred on the national level.” Instead of screaming about what we do not like, if we could sit down and say, “What freedoms have been violated by this person’s actions? What types of intervention or securities of government intervention do we need to maintain the kind of freedom that we want to have?”

You gave a perfect example. Insider trading is something you and I cannot do. We would get put in jail over it, but there are a lot of people that are currently doing that, and it’s well known. In our discussions, we need to say that’s one thing we both can agree on. Insider trading is not acceptable. There’s nothing wrong with being wealthy. There’s nothing wrong with being successful. You do not do it in certain ways. When those ways appear in the environment or in the country or whatever, then we start saying, “Wait a minute. Ordinary Americans, what do we have the right to do, and then what do we need to do?”

What actions do we need to take to gain security in our country by saying, “No, you do not get to behave that way. Here are the laws. Here’s what is going to be investigated. Here’s what’s going to come into court.” You get your trial. I sit here today, and I say, if we could take just individual situations and talk about them, we may not agree. The agreement is not the issue. We need to talk about what we see in this situation and where the freedom was eroded, and where is the security and intervention we need to stop that erosion? Your turn.

It’s true in that regard. The other is, are we sacrificing some security as a consequence of these actions? I would say where we lack security, we will lack freedom. Now, it’s not to say that security is more important, but frankly, unless you’ve got a secure banking system, unless you’ve got a secure border, etc., then all of our freedoms are at risk. We have to be concerned about somebody robbing us on the beltway. Security, and that exists at so many levels, and there’s so many, not so much descriptions of it, but interpretations of the terms.

We talked about earlier national security, and that’s different. What we’re talking about often here is more of our personal security. The places where our individual freedoms, not so much societal freedoms, but where our individual freedoms are put at risk. Where our individual security is put at risk. If we lack confidence in government, then I think we’re going to start to feel insecure. We feel that our freedoms are going to be at risk. That tends to make us emotional. I do not know. It’s probably where we’re at as a society and maybe as individuals. It’s a good point.

If we think about where we’re at risk of losing freedoms, is that a consequence of somebody thinking that there’s more security? Is that just a consequence of people’s poor behavior? I’m going to say there’s a separation. There’s this constitutional interpretation, if you will, which is if we’re all equal, then we’ve all got the same freedoms. If we’re all equal under law, then everybody should be subject to the same law. But I think we’ve got a class system. That’s not to say that we need to go straight socialist. That’s not what I’m suggesting for a moment.

I know you wouldn’t suggest that.

We’ve got a class system that we’ve allowed. That’s irrespective of which administration’s in power. If we had elected officials that were truly tuning in to us, and probably if we as voters were able to explain what was of concern to us. I do not know if that gets us back to this whole education thing. I can tell you that AI and the technopoly are just going to make it worse because our bandwidth as individuals just gets narrower and narrower. We no longer bother to pick up a book. We log on and ask ChatGPT or Gemini, who’s bad, who’s good? Somehow or another, our opinions are formulated for us. That’s not healthy. I do not know how to stop it.

If we got a dozen people who tuned into this and started having the same conversations, maybe we’d be better off. To me, as an individual and with my beliefs, the biggest risk that I see is the other set of beliefs infringing on my liberties. It’s happened. It happened the other way around too. Again, irrespective of who’s in power. Somewhere, it feels like our liberties are at risk, the freedoms we enjoy are at risk, our security is at risk. I do not know that sensitivity ever goes away. It feels to me it’s a part of our lives all the time, pre-election, post-election. It doesn’t matter.

Nigel, what I’m saying is I think it’s gotten to the place where we cannot sit down and say, “Let’s take one moment of insight. Let’s use insider trading because it’s easy to do. Let’s take one incident that we know of insider trading, and we know that’s been happening significantly. What are we as voters going to do when we know that’s happening?” What are we going to say to our representatives and say, “No, it doesn’t matter what happened in the past. It matters what’s currently happening.

I cannot do anything about the past, but I can do something and vocalize it.” I’ll tell you something that happened to me the other night. I’m not going to say exactly what group I was in or anything, but this is a group where they have to listen to citizens, and they have to see what the citizens really care about. There were two sides presented, and then it was the decision of the group to decide what would really happen in this conflict, in this situation. What was really amazing to me is something that was said that was very inappropriate. It was unreasonable.

Luckily, there was a person there who could speak to that issue. It changed. I mean, what this woman did, she spoke with such clarity, named the behavior, named what our history is in America, named what the unacceptable things are, and named what the possibilities were for resolving it, that it came to a place where we could all sit there and say, “I see what we need to do here.” That’s what it requires.

The problem is we may decide to take one example in the headlines, and we may talk about it, and decide how we can have a conversation, and decide, “What freedoms are being threatened?” or “What freedoms are being given to this person that they wouldn’t give to the ordinary citizen? What securities do we have, or what actions do we need to take to prevent this from occurring?”It doesn’t matter who did it as much as it doesn’t need to be occurring.

What’s going on in our government, in our courts, I do not care whether it’s a city council, I do not care whether it’s a state legislature or whatever. We have to decide, “This is not acceptable. How are we going to talk about it?” My biggest problem is that the extremes are the ones that speak loudest. Those in the middle get so tired of hearing these streams that we quit talking.

It’s a bait and switch or diversion. If you think about insider trading, you could name names. Those individuals will deny, but then they’ll deflect. They’ll blame the other person for something else. That strategy is to blame your opponent, accuse your opponent of doing something, but then do the same thing yourself. You tell them that’s not important. You tell your populace that’s not important. We’ve just begun to ignore some of these bigger issues. Have we just become tolerant? Do we accept bad behavior from everybody?

Wait a minute, I’ll just say something. We’ve become too tolerant in the last two years. Nigel, what I’m saying is, it’s a small example of what I saw the other night. When the truth was spoken, both sides had the chance to do it. There was a clear message about behavior that was unacceptable because it would impact the decision. In one situation, it was talked through to the point where it was resolved. In another, a decision was made that I think is harmful. It’s harmful for my city. It’s harmful for the county. It will create more conflict because the people on this side are going to get real pissed, and then we’ll see what happens.

Now, hopefully, the people from the other side will come in and say, “No, let me tell you the factual data that I know. You need to consider this point of view.” If we can get out of blaming people and accusing people of stuff and talk from both sides, then I saw it the other night. I saw something amazingly resolved. I do not think the individual who called out their behavior they weren’t very happy, but they needed to be. It was appropriately done.

Civic Education And The Risks Facing A Republic

That’s a good outcome. Your comment, I’m going to push back on this one. You say over the last two years, I’ll tell you, man, four years prior to that, I think there was an abundance of tolerance as well. It’s not about saying who’s been more. It’s just that we as a society have decided that we’ll get polarized on some other issue. I do not know, because we’re allowed. We embrace that deflection. We listen to the loudest voice. As a bunch of people, I think that we’ve failed on education. We failed on our civics. There’s the risk of the empire. As with the Romans, there’s an abundance of history.

You can see the acts that lead up to that, the failure of an empire. We’re very much at risk of that. We’ve got the tools. We’ve got a constitution. We’re a republic. We’re not a democracy because there’s a handful of mechanical distinctions between those things. We should be very careful with the words that we use to describe this United States. Now, we’ve got the tools. We’ve got the framework. Are we actually going to do anything with them?

 

We’ve got the tools. We’ve got a constitution. We’re a republic, not a democracy, because of the fundamental mechanical distinctions between them.

 

My fear is, one way or the other, absent an educated populace holding the elected representatives to account and having courts, and this is not to draw fault with one or the other, but courts at every level, civic level, county level, etc., actually enforcing the law. By the time it gets to the Supreme Court, then lower courts have absolutely failed. It’s become this escape valve for whatever party, because they do not like the decision the lower court has made. I’m not sure that, constitutionally or legally, whatever the laws and policies, etc., have been followed.

It’s hard for any of us to track these things. We only ever hear the headlines or the results. It seems to us that it seems to me anyway, if things have to get to the Supreme Court, the lower courts have failed. They’ve either abdicated, or they’ve made some grievous errors. We see this because of district attorneys and federal prosecutors and all sorts of things. It’s become so partisan and driven by ideology. We’re at risk of just more of that. The partisanship, I do not know. You never get to get away from that. The ideology part of it, in my opinion, is the conservative doctrine and philosophy. That’s where I will stand and say, my ideology is not one of socialism, is not one of communism, it’s not one of democratic socialism.

Those things fundamentally affront me. If society accepts them, then I think that we’re cheating ourselves, our constitution, and denying ourselves a destiny. Now, none of those things have to happen, I do not think, to make you happy. The complete destruction of that ideology doesn’t necessarily make me happy. We’ve begun to say that’s an acceptable path. We’re no longer conservatives and liberals. We’re using the capital letters there.

Here’s the thing that I’ve come to realize. I enjoy talking with Reagan Republicans. I have all my life. I do not always support or decide that they have the right view, but I’ve had conversations with them. When you get to extremes, then it creates more problems. Now, here’s what I’ll say. I’ve been around for many, many years in the United States. So have you. I’m older than you are. The thing is, I think when I say, “I’m not going to deny. I will accept the fact that their decisions are made in a democratic administration and that they are different from those in Republicans.

The partisan issues really create difficulties in determining the best solution for the citizens of the United States that happen to be a part of those parties.” The thing I see, though, is, and this I will say. I know you’re going to get your chance to speak. What I’ve seen in the last two years is much more dramatic than anything I’ve seen in the past. If I look at Reagan’s administration, if I look at Biden’s, if I look at Obama’s, if I look at Bush’s, if I look at those administrations, I do not see those dramatic moves toward issues around respecting the rule of law and things like that.

We need to face the fact that there are times that we have worked very well together. People moved from one side of the aisle and resolved issues and got something good done. That’s the reason I’m sitting here talking to you. I do not know that we solved anything with what it is, but I do know this. I have a much clearer picture because I had two examples where I saw democracy functioning.

It had to call somebody out on their behavior so that the decision that was about to be made was one that would be good for the citizens. Another time, even though the behavior was called out, it was after the decision was made. I’m an expert in dealing with habitual patterns that people do. To me, if all you have the time to do is criticize and build cases with criticism, and you have no idea how to do feedback and feed forward and sharing like we’re trying to do, then we’re going to have conflict, and we’re going to have extreme things happening. I’ll stop there.

That’s exactly right. You mentioned the last two years. My fear is that it’s an arms race. The next two years, it’s just going to get worse. I do not know that anybody has the power to stop that. We’ve just decided that elections are going to be determined on the level of BS that’s called either way. Nobody, for the last, I’m going to say, three administrations has truly shown up with a set of solutions.

I have to support this. I do not think solutions have been provided to deal with the arms race, and we’re in a spot.

We cannot even identify what our problems are. We do not know what the finished product is supposed to look like. This is a thing that’s frustrated me for a very long time. Again, I’m not calling any party here at all. What we just hear is the rhetoric. It is vile. It is inflammatory. Frankly, it’s insulting. It’s full of character assassination. I’m finished with all the adjectives there. None of it is truly saying we’re going to solve a problem.

In fact, a lot of it is saying there’s a new problem over here, and it’s almost like it’s a bait-and-switch again. We’re going to identify a problem, and we’re going to tell you that we’re the only drug that can cure it. Now, I think ultimately, if I go back and I look at the Constitution and the Federalist Papers and such, in my head, I have a vision of what they thought this country should be. It’s still pretty accurate. It probably needs to be spoken to. There’s some modernization of that vision because we have the reality, of course.

We have to modernize the vision. We have to redo it. We have to put it in the present day.

The vision is one thing. The actual documentation underlying it, the Constitution. My opinion is, I do not know that it’s got to be changed. In light of where we find ourselves, whether it’s the geopolitical threat we face, religious ideology, any number of things that we know are genuine threats out there. How do we address those? I do not think you can continue to address these from the biblical point of view of live and let live. No, I’m sorry, there are enemies. Frankly, at the end of the fight, I want it to be the United States that’s still standing. We can talk about some of the Reagan doctrine as well.

Strength through cooperation, these sorts of things. That’s okay. I do not want to sacrifice the security of this nation and our culture just to, with all due respect, make the European Union happy. To hell with them, quite frankly. I do not say that as an isolationist. I just say that in the harsh light of political and geopolitical reality. They’re unable to help us. They’ve got greater problems than we have. It’s like a bad relationship.

At some point, you probably just have to decide, “I cannot live like that any longer. I’ve had jobs like that where I’ve had to walk away.” I do not know if we’re at that point, but I think it’s worth examining that. What are we going to do with this republic of ours? I do not know that we share a vision any longer. That’s just across the nation, not so much you and I. Maybe we have to spend some time redefining that vision and then thinking about what actions are necessary to realize it.

Geopolitical Realities And The Importance Of Alliances

That’s true. Now, I am a big supporter of alliances, which we’ll talk about in the future. I have seen some major changes in the European Union, based on things that have happened in the last few years, and we’ll talk about alliances because I believe in them. I do think that a friendship and alliance that we built for many years with Canada or other countries can be beneficial to us. One of the things we’ll get into is talking about that, because we have countries like China that have a billion people, and we have our size in our country. We also can determine what are the best ways we can build those alliances so they are beneficial to all. I’m not an isolationist. I truly believe, and I do not think you are either, Nigel.

No, I’m not. I’m going to say here’s our timeline down. Unfortunately, it’s revolved back to a security, liberty, freedom thing. If you want to build alliances, does that mean that we have to adopt a political doctrine? We have to adopt a I’m trying to think, it was Canada in particular that demanded products, French-language laws in Canada, trade barriers, etc., that sort of thing. There’s detail if people want to look that up. Are we in the interest of building an alliance? Do we want to sacrifice some of our freedoms? That’s a conversation to have in the future.

Alliances are okay. We’ve all got friends. We’ve all got business relationships we’ve established because they’re beneficial to us, either because of their support or in the event of a pseudo trade war. We’ve got allies. We were responding to the market in certain ways. We’re trying to get the market to adopt. We use alliances, and we use relationships. We couldn’t afford in business or in life to sacrifice some of our values, our beliefs, just to have a friendship and do it. You and I have talked about that.

I’m not going to do that. I support what you’re saying because I know one thing. There may be religious differences between me and another person. That doesn’t mean I give up my belief structure, my values, or the concepts I have. I’m at least willing to listen to that other person and find out what theirs are. When it comes to situations where I know I’m not being heard from the other side, they are not interested in hearing a thing I have to say. They are no longer friends of mine.

I do need to close this, but I think that’s the hook that we started with. It’s convenient to round that up. Which is to say, to try and maintain a relationship or whatever. What do I have to sacrifice? Have I got to sacrifice my beliefs? It cannot just be one-sided. I do not know what the trade-off is. Maybe we’re trying to find a way to have that equation solved. It’s just not obvious how we get there. I do need to sign off. What a hoot it’s to have these conversations, Jackalyn. Thank you. I hope people tune in to this and then, when they go home or whatever, they open up. They can have the same conversation and try to solve some of these things. Maybe they’ll share some feedback, and we’ll learn from them as well.

I would love to hear some. I call it feed forward. I want us to move forward. It’s the same thing but with a slight change in feedback. What I’d like to say, Nigel, is that I think in our conversations, we’re not saying we have all the solutions. At least we’re talking about the things that concern us. If we continue to talk about the things that concern us, we will find solutions. I thank you very much. We need to go to alliances sometime. That’ll be a really enjoyable conversation.

You choose, but you look and see, because I think that’s one of our topics. You can decide. Thank you so much. To everyone, we are very appreciative of the time you take to tune in to us. Please know we’re not saying we have the solutions, but we are going to talk until we come to places where we have some things. At least we’ve given you ways that you may have a slight difference, but you still can have a conversation, and that allows us to find those solutions. Thanks a lot, Nigel.

Appreciate it.

Bye-bye.

 

Important Links

 

About Nigel M. Lakey

Hot Topic Bold Talk | Immigration PolicyOriginally from Western Canada, and one of three sons of immigrant parents, Nigel has been in Houston since 2000 when as part of a company reorganization, he relocated from Calgary. While he resisted for the first year, he eventually let Texas wash over him and embraced the thing that is Texas- he now sees it as his home.

A Mechanical Engineer by education but a marketer and innovator by vocation, Nigel has spent the majority of his 45 year professional career in the oilfield service and technology space, with a brief foray into private equity before returning to what he knows and understands best.

His career is marked with experience in innovative and disruptive business and technology solutions, and he’s spent considerable time in the C-suite of public and private companies. Well-travelled to some 70 countries Nigel has worked in interesting places with interesting people and has deep respect for culture and history. He can speak a few languages as a result and maintains close friendships with many people he’s met over the years.

While he is retired out of the corporate world since 2022, Nigel is unable to resist the siren call of industry and is co-founder of an energy services startup that is developing AI and ML solutions for the oilfield. He also maintains a consulting and advisory business. Nigel remains active in business and industry and at this time he is the Chair of the Communications and Editorial Committee for the Private Directors Association.

An avid SCUBA diver since 1985, Nigel is an Advanced Open Water instructor, as well as an Adaptive SCUBA instructor, bringing SCUBA to disabled and mobility-challenged veterans and others faced with ability challenges.

Nigel is regarded as an authentic and visionary leader, and a well-spoken and concise communicator, influencer, and thought partner. He has built and developed organizations, catalyzed and led transformational change, and excels in environments where dynamic thought is needed to address strategic and operational challenges.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *